Turn on cookies to sign in
Signing in saves your progress to your Curie account. We can only do that with cookies on — turn them on to continue.
Idaho's 2024 fentanyl trafficking law was sold as a tool to take down drug dealers — but a new investigation finds it's being used to prosecute people struggling with addiction. At least 30 of 90 reviewed cases lacked any evidence of dealing. Critics say mandatory minimums are blocking access to treatment and making recovery harder, while supporters insist the law deters cartels.
Idaho's 2024 fentanyl trafficking law was pitched by lawmakers as a way to crack down on drug dealers and cartels — but an investigation by InvestigateWest reveals it's sweeping up people who are simply using. The law allows prosecutors to charge anyone possessing 4 grams or 100 pills of fentanyl with trafficking, regardless of whether there's any evidence of sales or distribution. Of 90 cases reviewed, one-third lacked the typical markers of dealing — scales, ledgers, small bags — yet those individuals still faced mandatory minimum prison sentences of 3, 5, or 10 years.
Public health advocates argue the law is counterproductive, pushing people with addiction into the criminal justice system instead of treatment. Only 13 of the 134 people charged received substance use treatment, and that only happened through plea deals to lesser charges — the trafficking statute itself doesn't allow alternative sentencing.
Key Takeaways:
Why it matters: When trafficking laws don't distinguish between dealers and users, people with addiction face prison instead of treatment — making recovery harder and compounding public health harms rather than solving them.
